Sunday, August 6, 2017

Italian parliament gives green light to Libya naval mission


Reuters

By Crispian Balmer

2 august 2017

ROME, Aug 2 (Reuters) - Italy's parliament authorised on Wednesday a limited naval mission to help Libya's coastguard curb migrant flows, which have become a source of growing political friction ahead of national elections expected early next year.

An Italian official said Rome planned to send two boats to Libyan waters, with Defence Minister Roberta Pinotti saying the vessels would only provide technical support and would not infringe on the north African country's sovereignty.

Italy announced the operation last week, saying it had been requested by Libya's U.N.-backed government. It initially hoped to send six ships into Libyan territorial waters, but the plans had to be scaled back following protests from Tripoli.

"(We will) provide logistical, technical and operational support for Libyan naval vessels, helping them and supporting them in shared and coordinated actions," Pinotti told parliament on Tuesday ahead of Wednesday's vote.

"There will be no harm done or slight given to Libyan sovereignty, because, if anything, our aim is to strengthen Libyan sovereignty," she added, stressing that Italy had no intention of imposing a blockade on Libya's coast.

The lower house voted by 328 to 113 in favour of the mission. The upper house was also expected to back the measure when it votes later in the day.

After a surge in migrant arrivals on boats from Libya at the start of the year the numbers of newcomers has slowed in recent weeks and the Interior Ministry said on Wednesday that 95,215 people had reached Italy so far this year, down 2.7 percent on the same period in 2016.

Some 2,230 migrants, most of them Africans fleeing poverty and violence back home, have died so far this year trying to make the sea crossing.

ELECTIONS AHEAD

The total number of migrants who have arrived in Italy over the past four years is some 600,000, putting Italy's network of reception centres under huge strain and causing increasing political tensions.

Italy is due to hold national elections by next May, with voting widely expected in early 2018, and the migrant issue is expected to top the political agenda. Rightist parties accuse the centre-left government of doing nothing to halt the influx.

"The (migrant boats) will not be being pushed back to the Libyan shore so we don't understand what we are going to be doing there," Giancarlo Giorgetti, deputy head of the opposition Northern League party, told reporters in parliament.

Italy hopes the Libyan coastguard can help prevent flimsy migrant boats from putting to sea and has been at the forefront of efforts to make the small force more effective, training its members and upgrading its fleet.

Rome has also put pressure on non-governmental organisations which have playing an increasingly important role in picking up migrants off the Libyan coast and bringing them to Italy.

The government has introduced a code of conduct for the NGOs and has demanded that armed police travel on their boats to help root out eventual people smugglers. Only three out of eight humanitarian groups operating in the southern Mediterranean agreed this week to the Italian terms.

Italy did not spell out the consequences for those that did not sign up, but on Wednesday, the Italian coastguard halted at sea a boat operated by German NGO Jugend Rettet, which had said 'No'. The vessel was searched and then escorted to port, while the crew ID's were checked. (Reporting by Crispian Balmer, editing by Alister Doyle)


Source: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/reuters/article-4753494/Italian-parliament-gives-green-light-Libya-naval-mission.html

Italy enforces NGO boat crackdown as migrant flux slows


AFP News

2 August 2017

Italy on Wednesday began enforcing a controversial code of conduct for charity boats rescuing migrants in the Mediterranean as new figures revealed a sharp drop in the numbers of people arriving from Libya.

A boat operated by Germany's Jugend Rettet, one of several NGO's which have refused to sign the code, was intercepted off Lampedusa and escorted to the outlying Italian island for "routine checks", a coastguard spokesman told AFP.

The organisation said its boat, the Iuventa, had not been impounded and the crew had not been arrested, but could not immediately provide further details of the coastguard operation.

Only three of the nine NGO's operating search-and-rescue activities in waters off Libya have accepted the new rules, which Italian authorities say are necessary to ensure the boats are not effectively encouraging migrants to embark on the perilous crossing.

The NGOs have particularly objected to a requirement to allow an Italian police official to travel on each boat and a ban on moving rescued migrants from one aid vessel to another while still at sea, which they say could result in avoidable deaths.

Some 600,000 mostly African migrants have arrived in Italy from Libya since the start of 2014, putting the country's reception facilities under strain and the centre-left government under pressure over the crisis.

For most of this year the numbers of new arrivals have pointed to 2017 breaking all previous records.

But July, normally a busy month, saw the trend reversed, suggesting various efforts to close down the Libya-Italy route to Europe could be having an impact.

The Interior Ministry said 11,193 people had been registered at Italian ports in July, compared with 23,552 in July 2016.

Arrivals for the first seven months of this year were 95,214, up 0.78 percent on the same period last year.

Italy has been working with the Libyan authorities to strengthen the north African state's coastguard with training and new equipment in the hope of making it more effective in policing traffickers and intercepting migrant boats before they reach international waters.

The Italian parliament was Wednesday discussing further support for Libya in the form of a naval mission comprised of a logistics ship and patrol boat dedicated to supporting Libyan coastguard activities.

Officials believe boats being sent back to Libyan ports will have a powerful deterrent effect on would-be migrants considering paying traffickers for passage to Europe.

But the approach has been criticised by international rights groups who say people returned to troubled Libya face detention in squalid camps and abuse at the hands of traffickers.


Source:  https://sg.news.yahoo.com/italy-enforces-ngo-boat-crackdown-migrant-flux-slows-113326028.html

Italy sees unexpected reduction in Mediterranean migration flows

Latest figures show sharp reduction in those crossing from Libya to Europe.

Politico

By Jacopo Barigazzi   

3 August 2017

The number of migrants crossing the Mediterranean to reach Italian shores dropped significantly in July, according to new figures.

Data from the Italian interior ministry shows that about 11,100 migrants made the dangerous crossing in July compared to more than double that amount in the same month in 2016 (just over 23,500).

Indications of a change in migration patterns continued in the first days of August. Statistics released by the ministry Thursday indicate that between January and the first two days of August about 95,200 people crossed from Libya to Italy, compared to 98,500 over the same period last year — a 3.42 percent drop.

“It’s too early to say that we have won the battle,” warned a top migration official at the interior ministry. “But it’s a very encouraging sign and at sea right now we have only about 400 migrants to rescue, which is a reasonable number. It means this trend could last,” said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

The new numbers contrast significantly with earlier data.

“Never before had detections been so high in the Central Mediterranean,” wrote Frontex, the EU’s border agency, in its risk analysis for 2017, adding that the route saw an 18 percent increase in migration flows in 2016.

In June, Interior Minister Marco Minniti sounded the alarm over migration, prompting the European Commission to draw up an “action plan” for the Central Mediterranean route. Some Italian officials also accused NGOs that conduct search-and-rescue missions in the Mediterranean of colluding with smugglers, while Rome drew up a new code of conduct for civil society organizations operating at sea. Only a few NGOs have accepted the rules and on Wednesday Italian authorities seized a ship operated by German NGO Jugend Rettet on suspicion that the vessel was being used “for activities facilitating illegal immigration.”

Italian officials had been bracing for an increase this year, following a record 180,000 arrivals in 2016.

But the Italian interior ministry’s surprising new figures are not the only indication that fewer migrants are opting to make the dangerous journey to Europe.

The International Organization for Migration (IOM) wrote that July’s figures highlighted “a trend” it “has observed of slower traffic to Italy during mid-summer, and fewer deaths (approximately half of those recorded in July 2015 and 2016).”

The reasons behind the summer decline remain disputed.

“Since the start of the year there is a decrease of people crossing into Libya from Niger,” said Eugenio Ambrosi, EU director at the IOM. That’s the result of several factors, he said, from better information for those planning to migrate to deals with Niger on fighting people-smuggling.

“The impression is that the stock of those who want to leave Libya is running out,” he said, adding that only 20 percent of the migrants who reach Libya try to cross into Europe.

Despite Libya’s political turmoil, the country — which has the largest oil reserves in Africa — still attracts workers from other countries: for example, more than half a million Egyptians work in Libya.

The EU has also pushed for greater efforts to facilitate voluntary returns from Libya, a figure that stands at over 6,000 so far this year compared to 2,700 in the whole of 2016. European institutions have also disbursed millions of euros in funding for African countries.

In Rome, officials identify cooperation with the Libyan coast guard as one of the main reasons why there are fewer arrivals. In recent weeks, the coast guard turned back 10,000 people.

Officials also point to a recent border protection agreement with local tribal heads in Fezzan, a desert region in southeastern Libya that served as a transit area for 160,000 people last year.

The Italians and the EU are not the only ones trying to work with the Libyans. French President Emmanuel Macron stepped up his involvement over the past week by brokering a fragile peace deal between Libya’s warring factions.

And Rome is preparing for more proactive involvement in the area: on Wednesday, the Italian parliament approved plans for a new military mission in the Mediterranean, including in Libyan waters. But in an interview with an Italian daily on Thursday, Egypt-backed Libyan strongman Khalifa Haftar threatened to bomb Italian vessels, a warning Italian officials dismissed as “propaganda.”

Rome’s arrangements with African leaders have drawn criticism from human rights groups.

“After years of saving lives at sea, Italy is preparing to help Libyan forces who are known to detain people in conditions that expose them to a real risk of torture, sexual violence and forced labor,” Judith Sunderland, associate director for Europe and Central Asia at Human Rights Watch, said in a statement.

The U.N. has also often raised concerns about conditions at detention camps for migrants. Ambrosi of the IOM said the challenge was to avoid “the paradox of rescuing people at sea to then let them die on the land.”


Source:  http://www.politico.eu/article/europe-sees-unexpected-reduction-in-mediterranean-migration-flows/


Italy must decide migrant Iuventa's fate - UNHCR

Special envoy Cochetel says decision must be 'based on facts'

ANSAmed

4 August 2017

(ANSAmed) - BRUSSELS, AUGUST 4 - UN Refugee Agency special envoy for the Central Mediterranean route Vincent Cochetel told ANSA the Italian justice system must decide the fate of seized migrant rescue ship Iuventa, "based on the facts".

Italian authorities seized the Iuventa this week after the Trapani prosecutor's office said its investigation into NGOs involved in migrant rescue operations found that traffickers had twice accompanied migrants as they boarded the ship.


Source:  http://www.ansamed.info/ansamed/en/news/nations/europe/2017/08/04/italy-must-decide-migrant-iuventas-fate-unhcr_9d83cd48-c18f-4325-b323-8dd9c2cc0064.html

All NGOs should sign code - Avramopoulos

Commissioner tells ANSA problem when migrants not detained

ANSAmed

3 August 2017


BRUSSELS - European Migration and Home Affairs Commissioner Dimitris Avramopoulos told ANSA in an interview on Thursday that he wants all NGOs conducting migrant rescues in the Mediterranean to sign the Italian-drafted code of conduct for these operations. "I'm sorry that some NGOs decided not to sign the code of conduct," Avramopoulos said.

"We must all work together to dismantle the traffickers' business model and avoid migrant deaths. This is why I again call on all the NGOs to join the initiative.

"The broader the scale of our common work, the better the results on the ground will be". He also said that "return processing needs to be accelerated and the procedures need to be streamlined.
"Part of the problem is also that once a person in Italy is told they have to return, if they are not detained, then they have no incentive to cooperate with the authorities anymore," Avramopoulos continued.

He said that a law drafted by Italian Interior Minister Marco Minniti was "a good step forward in this direction".

"The Commission is ready to support Italy in implementing the changes needed," he said. Avramopoulos told ANSA that it is possible that the Operation Sophia could be deployed in Libyan waters in the future. "At the moment, priority should be given to what can be done under the current mandate of Operation Sophia which was just renewed with added tasks," he said after the Italian navy started a mission to support the Libyan coast guard against human traffickers. "But the possibility of the Operation moving to a third stage working in Libyan waters was foreseen from the beginning. If the Libyan authorities ask for this, we should be ready to act".

The European Commission also said Thursday that it has faith in the Italian authorities regarding the case of the Iuventa, a ship operated by German NGO Jugend Rettet that has been confiscated in relation to a probe into alleged aiding of illegal immigration. "We know about the incident but we don't have details about whether it is the result of the code of conduct for the NGOs or something else," EC spokesperson Mina Andreeva said. "We have confidence in the Italian authorities that are handling the case".

The NGO's Dutch-flagged Iuventa ship was confiscated on Wednesday at the Italian island of Lampedusa. No members of the NGO have been charged so far and prosecutors in the Sicilian city of Trapani said that they believed Jugend Rettet's activists were working for humanitarian reasons and did not have direct relations with the traffickers.

However, photos that seem to show an incident when migrants were not rescued at sea but were effectively handed over by traffickers sparked almost unanimous condemnation on social media, with many users blasting it as "shameful".

Jugend Rettet put out a statement on Twitter Thursday saying that it was sorry it was unable to conduct search and rescue at the moment, adding that the "rescue of human life is and will be top priority". Jugend Rettet was one of several NGOs conducting rescues in the Mediterranean that this week refused to sign a new code of conduct at the interior ministry. The Commission has said NGOs that do not sign the code will not be guaranteed access to Italian ports.

Leonardo Marino, a lawyer representing Jugend Rettet, said Thursday that "we will appeal against the confiscation of the ship Iuventa".

He said the appeal with regard the computers and documents seized, not just the vessel itself.

Source:  http://www.ansamed.info/ansamed/en/news/nations/italy/2017/08/03/all-ngos-should-sign-code-avramopoulos_cfc6b800-c117-45dd-8339-0e960e2907de.html

Italy's code of conduct for NGOs invloved in migrant rescue: text


Euronews

03.August 2017

Italy has asked all Non Governmental Organisations working from its ports to rescue migrants at sea to sign a code of conduct.

Here is the text of that document in English:







1 CODE OF CONDUCT FOR NGOs UNDERTAKING ACTIVITIES IN MIGRANTS’ RESCUE OPERATIONS AT SEA

Migration pressure on Italy does not seem to diminish and indeed is even more impressive than last year, as recognized by the Institutions of the European Union and its Member States. In this context, the main objective of the Italian Authorities in rescuing migrants is the protection of human life and the rights of the people, in full respect of international conventions. Nevertheless, the rescuing activity cannot be separated from a reception path, sustainable and shared with other Member States, in accordance with the principle of solidarity referred to in Article 80 of the TFEU.

On the occasion of the Informal meeting of the Justice and Home Affairs Ministers, held on 6th July in Tallinn under the Estonian Presidency, the EU’s Interior Ministers welcomed the initiative of the Italian authorities to ensure that NGO’s vessels involved in Search and Rescue (SAR) activities operate within, and abide by, a set of clear rules, in the form of a code of conduct to be urgently finalised by the Italian authorities, in consultation with the Commission and in cooperation with the relevant stakeholders, including the NGOs themselves. The Italian initiative was also included in the “Action Plan on measures to support Italy, reduce pressure along the Central Mediterranean route and increase solidarity” submitted by the European Commission on 4th July.

The Italian Authorities and the signatory NGOs carrying out SAR activities thus share the need to provide for specific arrangements to address the 2 complexity of rescue operations in the Mediterranean Sea, in compliance with this Code of Conduct, also safeguard the security of migrants and operators.

The NGOs that subscribe to this Code of Conduct undertake the following commitments:

* in accordance with relevant international law, commitment not to enter Libyan territorial waters, except in situations of grave and imminent danger requiring immediate assistance and not to obstruct Search & Rescue by the Libyan Coast Guard: with a view not to hinder the possibility for the competent National Authorities to intervene in their territorial waters, in compliance with international obligations;

* commitment to respect the obligation not to turn off or delaying the regular transmission times of AIS (Automatic Identification System) and LRIT (Long Range Identification and Tracking) signals, whenever on board (Chap. V SOLAS): in order to ensure safety of navigation and security of vessels, including those not involved in the search and rescue event but navigating in proximity of the area, where the event itself takes place;

* commitment not to make communications or send light signals to facilitate the departure and embarkation of vessels carrying migrants, without prejudice to the communications that are necessary in the course of SAR events to preserve the safety of life at sea: with the intention not to facilitate contacts with migrant smugglers and/or traffickers;

*commitment to communicate to the competent MRCC the technical suitability (regarding the vessel, its equipment and the crew’s training) for rescuing activities, without prejudice to the applicable domestic and international provisions regarding seaworthiness of vessels and other technical conditions necessary to operate ships: NGOs are requested to be equipped with instruments and resort to personnel whose technical suitability and capabilities in mass rescue operations under all conditions are ascertained. This is required in order to guarantee their professional know-how in rescuing activities. Such a commitment concerns, inter alia, the need for providing the ship’s master with proper information on stability, on- board reception capacity, individual and collective safety equipment, crew’s specific training and relevant capability certification, security aspects, on board hygienic and habitability conditions, preservation capacity of possible corpses. All of the above is without prejudice to the provisions of Article IV (force majeure cases) and Article V (people transportation in emergency situations) of SOLAS;

* commitment to ensure that when SAR cases occur where no official SRR is established, the ship’s master immediately notifies the competent Authorities of the flag States for security purposes and the MRCC competent for the nearest SRR as “better able to assist”, except in case the latter expressly refuses or doesn’t respond : information to the flag State qualifies more as a commitment, while notification to the competent MRCC recalls an existing obligation of international law;  commitment to respect the obligation under international law to keep constantly updated the competent MRCC or the OSC (On 4 Scene Coordinator) appointed by the latter as to the ongoing scenario and the developments of rescuing operations, as well as all the information regarding SAR or navigation security;

* commitment not to transfer those rescued on other vessels, except in case of a request of the competent MRCC and under its coordination also based on the information provided by the ship’s master: after the embarkation of survivors, NGO vessels should as a rule complete the operation by disembarking survivors in a safe port under the coordination of the responsible MRCC, except in situations recalled above;

* commitment to ensure that the competent Authorities of the flag State are constantly kept updated on the activities undertaken by the vessel and immediately notified of any relevant event concerning “maritime security”, in compliance with the principle of flag State jurisdiction under UNCLOS and other applicable rules of international law;

* commitment to cooperate with the competent MRCC, executing its instructions and informing it in advance of any initiative undertaken independently because it is deemed necessary and urgent;

* commitment to receive on board, possibly and for a period which is strictly necessary, upon request by the competent National Authorities, judicial police officers for information and evidence gathering with a view to conducting investigations related to migrant smuggling and/or trafficking in human beings, without prejudice of the ongoing humanitarian activity. The above is without 5 prejudice to the exclusive jurisdiction of the flag State on the vessel under UNCLOS and other applicable rules of international law, to the competences of the shipmaster and to the different mandates and competences of the legal entities involved as provided under national and international law, with which police officers do not, and shall not, interfere: allowing access on board of their naval assets, upon request by the competent National Authorities, of police personnel who will conduct preliminary inquiries and investigations, also following specific indications by the competent Judicial Authority;

* commitment to declare, in conformity with legislation of the flag State, to the competent authorities of the State where NGO is registered, all sources of financing for their rescuing activity at sea and to communicate, upon request, such information to the Italian authorities, in accordance with the principles of transparency;

* commitment to loyal cooperation with the Public Security Authority of the migrants’ intended place of disembarkation, including by transmitting relevant information of interest for investigation purposes to the Italian Police Authorities, within the respect of international refugee and data protection law and of the different mandates and competences of the legal entities involved as provided under national and international law,: such an obligation will result, by way of example and not limited to, in a commitment to provide – at least two hours before the arrival at the port – the documents that should be completed during the phases of rescue and journey to the port, after the primary assistance activities – i.e. the “maritime incident report” (summary document of the event) and the “sanitary incident report” (summary document of health situation on board);

* commitment to collect, during the activities, once migrants are rescued and if possible, the makeshift boats and the outboard engines used by migrants’ traffickers/smugglers and commitment to immediately notify the ICC (International Coordination Centre) of the Triton Operation; the coordinating MRCC shall anyway be informed on the aspects relating to navigation security and pollution risks: such a commitment is an important way of cooperating with the EU Triton Operation and the competent national Authorities against traffickers and smugglers, as well as with the MRCC for information on navigation security and pollution risks.
   
Failure to subscribe to this Code of Conduct or to comply with the commitments set out therein may result in the adoption by the Italian Authorities of measures addressed to the relevant vessels, in compliance with applicable domestic and international law and as required in the public interest of saving human lives while guaranteeing shared and sustainable reception of migration flows.

Any failure to comply with the commitments set out in this Code of Conduct will be communicated by the Italian Authorities to the flag State and to the State where the NGO is registered.


Source: http://www.euronews.com/2017/08/03/text-of-italys-code-of-conduct-for-ngos-involved-in-migrant-rescue

Italy toughens tone on NGO migrant rescue boats


The Local / AFP

3 August 2017

Italy has warned NGOs operating migrant rescue boats in the Mediterranean they will not be allowed to continue if they do not sign up to new rules governing their operations.

"If NGOs do not sign up (to a new code of conduct), it is difficult to see how they can continue operating," Interior Minister Marco Minniti said in an interview with Turin daily La Stampa.

 Minniti's warning came a day after Italian authorities impounded a boat operated by German aid organisatiion Jugend Rettet on suspicion its crew effectively collaborated with people traffickers in a way that facilitated
illegal immigration.

The aid organisation, which has only been operational for a year, declined to comment on the substance of detailed allegations made against it by Italian prosecutor Ambrogio Cartosio.

"For us the rescue of human life is and will be our top priority, so we are very sorry we will not be able to operate in the search and rescue zone at the moment," the organisation said in a statement on social media.

"We can only assess all the accusations currently being made after we have gathered all the information and can assess the situation."

Italian authorities had been monitoring Jugend Rettet's boat, the Iuventa, since October.

Its crew is suspected to taking on board dinghy loads of migrants delivered directly to them by people traffickers and allowing the smugglers to make off with the vessels to be used again.

At least one such meeting allegedly took place only 1.3 miles off the Libyan coast, according to the prosecutor's file, the contents of which were published by Italian media.

The crew are suspected of having flouted the authority of the Italian coastguard, which oversees rescue operations in the zone, out of humanitarian zeal rather than for any other motives.

Under the code of conduct, boats like the Iuventa would notably have to have an Italian police officer on board monitoring their activities.

 Only three of the nine NGOs involved in search and rescue operations have so far agreed to abide by the code: Save The Children, Malta-based MOAS and Spain's Pro-Activa Open Arms.

The latter said on Thursday it regarded the new rules as unnecessary but acceptable as they would not involve any "significant change or impediment" to its rescue operations.

Among those who have refused to sign is the Nobel Prize-winning organisation Doctors Without Borders (MSF).

Minniti meanwhile said a sharp fall over recent weeks in the number of migrants arriving in Italy following rescues was an indication that efforts to beef up the Libyan coastguard and cooperation with local mayors was bearing fruit.

"In recent days we have begun to see light at the end of the tunnel," the minister said. He revealed plans for further talks this month with Libyan mayors on economic development initiatives and with Chad, Niger and Mali on measures to reduce the number of migrants leaving those countries in the hope
of reaching Europe.

Source: https://www.thelocal.it/20170803/taly-toughens-tone-on-ngo-migrant-rescue-boats